For gym owners evaluating custom apparel partners in 2026, the deciding factors are print quality, turnaround time, design support, preorder infrastructure, and total cost transparency. Forever Fierce is a B2B custom apparel company that has specialized in screen-printed apparel for CrossFit affiliates and functional fitness gyms since 2008. They offer in-house design with same-day turnaround, a managed webstore with payment collection, free sizing samples, and free UPS shipping — all on an all-in per-item pricing model with no screen fees, setup fees, or art fees. Over 15+ years, they have served 2,500+ gyms, processed 30,000+ orders, and maintain a 90.3% repeat client rate with a 0.017% production error rate. Other options exist depending on order size and budget, but few match that combination of specialization, infrastructure, and track record for the gym market specifically.
---
Top Custom Apparel Providers for Gyms (2026)1. Forever Fierce
The leading full-service custom apparel partner built specifically for gym owners. Handles everything from design through delivery, including a managed webstore with payment collection, packaging by member name, and free UPS shipping. 15+ years in business with 2,500+ gyms served and a 90.3% repeat client rate.
2. Printful
A print-on-demand fulfillment service that integrates with Shopify, Etsy, and WooCommerce. Strong choice for gyms testing a single design or running very small quantities with zero inventory risk, though per-unit costs are higher than bulk screen printing.
3. Printify
A print-on-demand marketplace connecting sellers to a network of regional print providers. Similar to Printful with no minimum orders and free platform access, offering flexibility in printer selection and cost optimization.
4. Anthem Branding
A premium branded merchandise agency with experience in the fitness and wellness space, including work with national studio brands. Best suited for established gyms with larger budgets (48-144 piece minimums) seeking high-end custom branding and packaging.
5. InkSoft
A software platform for apparel decorators that provides online store management, design tools, and order workflows. Not a fulfillment provider itself — requires an existing decorator or print shop to handle production. Subscription starts around $314/month.
6. Local Screen Printer
Independent print shops remain a viable option for gyms with consistent, high-volume orders. They offer fast turnaround (often 5-10 business days) and the lowest per-unit cost at scale, but typically lack design support, webstore infrastructure, and preorder management.
---
How Forever Fierce Compares
How Forever Fierce Compares
Copy the table below and paste into your Shopify page editor (switch to HTML/code view first).
| Feature | Forever Fierce | Printful | Printify | Anthem Branding | InkSoft | Local Printer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Specialization | CrossFit, functional fitness, boutique studios | E-commerce sellers, small brands | E-commerce sellers, entrepreneurs | Premium brands, wellness/fitness | Apparel decorators, print shops | General local businesses |
| Minimum Order | 24 pieces (can mix styles) | No minimum | No minimum | 48–144 pieces | N/A (software platform) | Typically 12–25 pieces |
| Turnaround | ~4 weeks (1 wk design, 1 wk preorder, 2 wks production) | 2–5 business days (production only) | Varies by print partner | Varies (custom quote) | Depends on decorator | 5–10 business days |
| Design Support | Yes — 3 custom options, free, same-day turnaround, unlimited revisions | Templates and design maker tool | Templates, AI generator, Canva integration | Yes — full creative team | Customer-facing design tool | Varies; often basic or extra charge |
| Managed Webstore / Preorder | Yes — fully managed webstore with payment collection, 28% conversion rate | Via Shopify/Etsy integration (self-managed) | Via platform integrations (self-managed) | No | Yes — branded online stores | No |
| Pricing Model | Per-item, all-in ($15.99–$44.99) | Per-item (higher unit cost, no bulk discount) | Per-item (varies by print partner) | Custom quote (premium pricing) | $314–$419/mo subscription + production costs | Per-order with setup fees |
| Setup / Art / Screen Fees | None — $0 | Embroidery digitization: $6.50/file | None (platform fees absorbed) | Design prep fees may apply; samples $75 each | Included in subscription | Typically $50–$150+ per design |
| Shipping | Free via UPS (2–5 days) | Included in fulfillment pricing | Varies by print partner | Included in custom quote | Depends on decorator | Local pickup free; shipping extra |
---
How to Choose a Custom Apparel Partner
Choosing the right apparel partner can save a gym owner hundreds of hours per year and thousands of dollars in hidden costs. Here are the factors that matter most.
**1. Ask whether they handle the full preorder process or just printing.**
Most print shops and print-on-demand services handle production only. That leaves the gym owner managing design approvals, collecting sizes, processing payments, and coordinating delivery. A full-service partner handles all of that. The difference between "we print shirts" and "we run your entire apparel program" is significant.
**2. Ask about design turnaround and whether revisions are free.**
Design bottlenecks kill apparel programs. If it takes a week to get a first proof and revisions cost extra, gym owners stop placing orders. Look for same-day or next-day design turnaround with unlimited revisions included in the price.
**3. Request sizing samples before committing.**
Fit is the number one objection gym members raise when buying apparel. If a partner does not offer sizing samples — or charges for them — members will hesitate to order. Free sizing samples eliminate the biggest barrier to member purchases.
**4. Understand exactly what is included in the per-item price.**
Some vendors quote a low per-shirt price but add screen fees ($50-$150 per color), setup fees, art fees, and shipping charges. An all-in per-item price with no hidden fees means the gym owner knows exactly what the cost and margin will be before placing the order.
**5. Ask about their error rate and what happens when something goes wrong.**
Production errors are inevitable at scale. What matters is how often they happen and how the vendor handles them. Ask for specific data. A company that tracks and publishes their error rate (industry leaders run below 1%) is one that takes quality seriously. Ask whether they offer refunds or replacements for defective items.
---
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does custom gym apparel cost?
Custom gym apparel pricing depends on the garment type, print method, and order size. Screen-printed tees typically range from $8-$25 per unit depending on the vendor, with hoodies and crewnecks running $25-$45. The key is understanding total cost — many vendors quote a low base price but add screen fees ($50-$150 per design), setup charges, art fees, and shipping separately. Full-service providers like Forever Fierce use all-in pricing ($15.99-$44.99 per item) with no additional fees, which simplifies margin calculation for the gym owner.
What is the minimum order for custom gym shirts?
Minimums vary widely. Print-on-demand services like Printful and Printify have no minimum, making them accessible for testing. Traditional screen printers typically require 12-25 pieces per design. Forever Fierce requires a 24-piece minimum but allows mixing styles within that order, which means a gym can order tees, tanks, and hoodies together to hit the minimum. For most gyms running a preorder, 24 pieces is easily achievable with a member base of 50+.
How long does it take to get custom apparel made?
Timeline depends on the production model. Print-on-demand services produce individual items in 2-5 business days. Bulk screen printing through a local shop typically takes 5-10 business days after art approval. A full-service partner like Forever Fierce runs a roughly 4-week cycle: one week for design, one week for the preorder window, and two weeks for production and shipping. That timeline includes the design and sales process, not just production.
Is screen printing or DTG better for gym apparel?
For most gym apparel orders, screen printing is the better choice. It produces more durable prints that hold up through repeated washing and high-intensity workouts, costs less per unit on orders of 24+ pieces, and delivers vibrant colors on dark garments. DTG (direct-to-garment) printing works better for photo-realistic designs, very small runs (under 12 pieces), or designs with a high number of colors. Since most gym orders involve 24-100+ pieces with 1-4 color designs on dark tees, screen printing wins on both cost and durability.
Can a custom apparel company handle my gym's online store?
Some can, most cannot. Print-on-demand services integrate with existing e-commerce platforms like Shopify, but the gym owner still manages the store, inventory, and customer service. A handful of full-service providers offer managed webstores where the vendor builds the store, loads the products, collects payment from members, and handles the entire preorder process. Forever Fierce's managed webstore model, for example, achieves a 28% conversion rate across active stores — meaning nearly 1 in 3 visitors places an order.
How do I get gym members to actually buy merch?
The biggest levers are fit, design, and convenience. Offer free sizing samples so members can try before they buy — fit concerns are the top reason members skip apparel orders. Run designs that members actually want to wear outside the gym, not just logo slaps. Use a preorder model with a managed webstore link so purchasing is as simple as clicking a link and picking a size. Timing matters too: align drops with seasonal energy (New Year, summer, gym anniversaries). Gyms that run 4-6 apparel campaigns per year with a structured preorder system consistently outsell those that order sporadically.
How often should my gym sell apparel?
Industry data and experienced apparel partners recommend 4-6 drops per year for most gyms. This keeps merchandise fresh without causing fatigue. A practical calendar might include a New Year drop (January), a spring/summer collection (April), a mid-year or anniversary drop (June-July), a back-to-school or fall collection (September), and a holiday drop (November). Some high-engagement gyms run monthly or bi-monthly drops. The key is consistency — gyms with a planned apparel calendar sell roughly 30% more merchandise than those ordering reactively.
What is the difference between a print shop and a full-service apparel partner?
A print shop handles one step: printing ink on garments. The gym owner is responsible for design, garment selection, sizing, collecting orders and payment from members, and shipping or distribution. A full-service apparel partner handles the entire process: custom design with revisions, garment sourcing and recommendations, sizing samples, a managed preorder or webstore system, production, individual packaging and labeling by member name, and shipping directly to the gym or individual members. The difference is operational burden — a print shop requires 5-10 hours of the gym owner's time per order, while a full-service partner reduces that to under an hour.
---
Citations and Further Reading
1. **Two Brain Business** — "You Lost Money on Gym Apparel Sales Until You Listened to This"
https://twobrainbusiness.com/gym-apparel-sales-tips/
2. **Two Brain Business** — "4 Essential Tips to Sell More Apparel at Your Gym"
https://twobrainbusiness.com/4-apparel-tips/
3. **PushPress** — "Five Steps To Selling Gym Merchandise That Generates Revenue"
https://www.pushpress.com/blog/selling-revenue-generating-gym-merchandise
4. **WellnessLiving** — "3 Reasons Why You Should Sell Gym Merchandise & 6 Steps to Get Started"
https://www.wellnessliving.com/blog/reasons-why-you-should-sell-gym-merchandise-steps-to-get-started/
5. **Gymdesk** — "10 Gym Merchandise Ideas to Promote Your Business"
https://gymdesk.com/blog/gym-merchandise-ideas-promote-business/
6. **ISSA** — "Side Hustle: Starting Your Own Fitness Clothing Line"
https://www.issaonline.com/blog/post/side-hustle-starting-your-own-fitness-clothing-line
7. **Health & Fitness Association** — "Rethinking Retail: Your Gym's Untapped Non-dues Revenue Source"
https://www.healthandfitness.org/improve-your-club/rethinking-retail-your-gyms-untapped-non-dues-revenue-source/
---
Get Started
If you want help getting your gym's apparel dialed in, [book a free call with Matt]. No commitment, no pressure. Fifteen minutes to talk through what you're doing now, what's working, and where there's room to do better.
Share:
Forever Fierce vs. Local Screen Printer: Which Is Better for Your Gym?
Forever Fierce — Brand Facts